Affordable Thrills: A Detailed Look at the Toyota GR86 vs. Subaru BRZ

In the realm of sports cars, affordability can be a relative term. But for driving enthusiasts seeking a pure, engaging experience without breaking the bank, the Toyota GR86 and Subaru BRZ stand out. These two rear-wheel-drive coupes are the latest iteration of a collaborative effort, offering a thrilling blend of performance, practicality, and value. But with near-identical specs, which one emerges victorious? Let's delve into the details of the GR86 and BRZ to help you decide.

Shared DNA, Individual Flavors

The GR86 and BRZ are twins born from a joint project between Toyota and Subaru. This translates to a near-identical driving experience. Both boast a sublime 2.4-liter, naturally-aspirated, four-cylinder boxer engine, producing a healthy 228 horsepower and 184 lb-ft of torque. This engine configuration, with its horizontally opposed pistons, contributes to a lower center of gravity, enhancing handling and agility.

Power is channeled through either a smooth-shifting six-speed manual transmission or an optional responsive eight-speed automatic. Both options propel these lightweight coupes from 0-60 mph in a respectable 5.4 seconds, delivering a satisfying rush of acceleration.

Steering the Course: Handling Nuances

While their technical underpinnings are the same, subtle differences emerge in how the GR86 and BRZ handle. Toyota equips the GR86 with slightly stiffer suspension components, translating to a sharper, more communicative steering feel. This setup might appeal to drivers who prioritize precision and feedback on twisty roads.

The BRZ, on the other hand, leans towards a slightly more comfortable ride. Its suspension offers a touch more compliance, making it a better companion for daily commutes or uneven road surfaces. This doesn't mean the BRZ sacrifices handling prowess. It remains a well-balanced and engaging sports car, just with a tinge more emphasis on everyday usability.

Aesthetic Appeal: A Matter of Taste

Both the GR86 and BRZ have received significant styling updates compared to their predecessors. The GR86 adopts a more aggressive look with a prominent front grille and functional air vents on the hood. The overall design language is reminiscent of classic Toyota sports cars, like the Supra, with a focus on aerodynamic efficiency.

The BRZ takes a more subtly sculpted approach. Its design retains the smooth curves and flowing lines that have been characteristic of the BRZ lineage. It still manages to look modern and sporty, but with a hint of elegance. Ultimately, the choice between these two comes down to personal preference.

Interior Comforts (or Lack Thereof)

Let's be honest, neither the GR86 nor the BRZ excels in offering a luxurious cabin experience. Their focus lies squarely on driving dynamics. However, the interiors have been significantly improved compared to the previous generation. The materials used feel more upscale, and the overall layout prioritizes ergonomics and functionality.

Both cars offer comfortable and supportive front seats that hold you in place during spirited driving. However, rear seats are best suited for occasional use or throwing in some gear. Cargo space is also minimal, but that's a common sacrifice in the name of a sleek and sporty design.

Tech and Features: Finding the Balance

The GR86 and BRZ come surprisingly well-equipped for their price point. Both offer an 8-inch infotainment touchscreen with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto compatibility. The system is intuitive and easy to use, although not the most cutting-edge. A six-speaker audio system provides decent sound quality, and a digital instrument cluster keeps essential information within the driver's field of view.

In terms of driver assistance features, both cars offer standard automatic emergency braking and forward-collision warning. Higher trim levels add features like blind-spot monitoring and lane departure warning. While not the most comprehensive suite of driver aids, it provides a good balance between keeping you safe and maintaining a driver-focused experience.

The Toyota Advantage: A Performance Bonus

One key differentiator between the GR86 and BRZ is a Toyota-exclusive perk. Every GR86 purchase includes a complimentary high-performance driving experience and a one-year membership to the National Auto Sport Association (NASA). This is a fantastic opportunity for new owners to hone their skills on a racetrack in a safe and controlled environment.

Subaru's Edge: A Legacy of Reliability

Subaru has a well-earned reputation for building reliable and dependable vehicles. This translates to potentially lower ownership costs in the long run. While the GR86 is still too new to establish a reliability track record, Subaru's proven record might be a deciding factor for some buyers.

The Verdict: A Choice for the Driver 

Do you crave the absolute sharpest handling and a more aggressive aesthetic? Then the Toyota GR86 might be your perfect match. Its stiffer suspension and design flourishes cater to the driving purist.

However, if you prioritize a touch more comfort in your daily commute while still enjoying a thrilling driving experience, the Subaru BRZ might be the better choice. Its slightly softer suspension and more subtle styling might resonate more with you.

The complimentary performance driving experience offered with the GR86 is a definite perk, especially for those new to the world of performance driving. But Subaru's established reputation for reliability shouldn't be discounted either.

Whichever car you choose, both the GR86 and BRZ offer exceptional value for the price. They deliver an engaging driving experience, practicality for everyday use, and a sense of style that surpasses their price tag. Test driving both cars is the best way to determine which one truly connects with you on an emotional level.

Beyond the GR86 and BRZ: Exploring Alternatives

The affordable sports car segment offers a few other compelling options. Here's a quick look at two potential rivals:

• Nissan Z: This iconic nameplate has returned with a vengeance. The new Z boasts a powerful twin-turbo V6 engine and a retro-inspired design that pays homage to its heritage. While more expensive than the GR86 and BRZ, it offers a unique blend of power and nostalgia.
• Mazda MX-5 Miata: The undisputed champion of affordable convertibles, the MX-5 Miata prioritizes pure driving joy with its lightweight chassis, sharp handling, and engaging manual transmission. While not as powerful as the GR86 or BRZ, its focus on driver engagement and open-air thrills makes it a compelling alternative.

The Final Word: An Affordable Gateway to Performance

The Toyota GR86 and Subaru BRZ represent a fantastic opportunity for enthusiasts to enter the world of performance cars without breaking the bank. They offer a thrilling driving experience, a surprising amount of practicality, and a stylish presence. Whether you choose the slightly sharper GR86 or the more comfortable BRZ, you're guaranteed an exciting and rewarding ownership experience. So, buckle up, hit the open road, and rediscover the pure joy of driving.